I agree with a lot of my classmates that it was very interesting to get a better understanding of the Maya's day-to-day activities and lifestyle. In class, we have spent a lot of time talking about how the Mayas have been oppressed throughout the past 500 years. Understanding the oppression is important, but it is also important to talk about other, less dramatic aspects of the Maya's history and lifestyle.
The Mayas probably don't feel oppressed everyday; they are probably more concerned about taking care of their families and making sure their lives run smoothly. For most Mayas, day-to-day chores almost certainly take up more time than politics and talk about human rights. One of the other aspects that struck me about the reading was that it described the cynicism with which the Mayans in Tecpan view politics in general. In that way, the people of Tecpan reminded me of the United States; I think that a lot of Americans get excited about politics, but when their hopes are disapointed, they choose to focus on other things instead. I think that we are used to being disapointed and disenchanted with politics, and that the Mayans in Tecpan probably feel the same way.
The other part of the reading that stood out to me was the section on the murder of Bishop Juan Gerardi. Immediately when I read the subheading for that section, I thought about El Salvador and the murders of the Archbishop Romero, nuns, priests, lay workers, etc. that happened there during the late '70's and '80's. I think this is a sort of example that shows all of the similarities between what happened in Guatemala and what happened in other parts of Latin America.
More specifically, it reminded me again of the US's involvement. In El Salvador, we also supported a very brutal dictatorship; When Salvadorian militarymen raped and killed 3 American nuns and one lay worker, we conducted a massive investigation (because they were Americans). Congress was even involved. The Reagan administration also knew about reports of widescale massacres in El Salvador by the military, particularly the El Mozote Massacre, in which all men, women, and children in few villages were systematically murdered. (The troops involved had been trained by US military and the weapons they used were made in the US and contributed to the El Salvadorian army with US funds.) However, even after these events became public, the US continued supporting El Salvador's government.
I think I went into more detail on that than I intended. Also, I know that the US has done some really great, humanitarian things as well. However, in my opinion, those actions don't simply negate what the CIA and government did during the Cold War. You can see the similarities between what happened in Guatemala and what happened in El Salvador. My question is: why don't more people know/care about this?? There have been investigations (by the UN, FBI, etc.) and there is really no way of arguing that these tragedies didn't take place, and our government absolutely knew what was happening.
When are we (as a country) going to start taking responsibility for the way we are impacting the rest of the world? (A less extreme but more current example is the way we are forcing free-trade policies on other countries and then flooding their markets, hurting their own agricultural sectors and in effect changing rural agriculture-based villages.) To put it more specifically, we all live in a democracy. We can impact government (supposedly), so why don't more people react to what our government has done? Another thing we talked about in class two weeks ago, what is the CIA doing now? Are we naive enough to hope that they aren't doing these things anymore?
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Sara,
ReplyDeleteI think you make some great points about the way that day-to-day life probably supersedes political talk for most people most of the time, but I'd suggest another way of looking at it. Instead of seeing it as oppression only existing when they are talking about it, it can be useful to realize that they experience oppression as a daily context in which they live their lives and perform daily, mundane actions. The oppression doesn't go away just because they stop thinking about it; it just becomes something that they are willing to put up with silently.
For those of you who are curious to learn more about what Sara referred to happening in El Salvador, you can learn more from this short documentary on the School of the Americas: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HOeaG6-qsVc&feature=related
Tristan